Skip to content

IssuesCourts

Courts

Limit Supreme Court justices to a single 18-year term

Supreme Court justices hold office during good behavior, which in practice means until they retire or die. Vacancies are therefore irregular. One president may fill several seats and shape the Court for a generation. Another may fill none. A single 18-year term, staggered so one seat opens every two years, would give each four-year presidential term two appointments in ordinary times. Whether Congress can do this by statute, or only by constitutional amendment, is itself disputed. This question is about the term. It is not about adding seats.

0 ballots on the record, including demonstration ballots. Open the count

Arguments in favor

  • Regular vacancies would make each presidency carry the same number of appointments, instead of depending on death or a strategically timed retirement.
  • Eighteen years is long enough for independence and shorter than a tenure that can last forty years.
  • A known schedule could lower the stakes of any single confirmation fight.

Arguments in opposition

  • Life tenure was meant to insulate justices from political pressure. A fixed end date creates a known return to private life and future employers.
  • A scheduled vacancy every two years could make the Court a permanent campaign issue.
  • If the change is attempted by statute rather than amendment, it will face an immediate constitutional challenge, including from the Court itself.

These points summarize claims often made about this proposition. They are not a party platform, and CitizenVote does not endorse them. Both columns are given the same space.