Skip to content

IssuesElections

Elections

Elect the president by nationwide popular vote

The president is chosen by electors allotted mostly by state, not by the national raw total of votes. Nearly every state gives all of its electors to the statewide winner. A candidate can therefore win the presidency with fewer individual votes than the runner-up, and campaigns concentrate on a smaller set of competitive states. Replacing the system with a nationwide popular vote would require a constitutional amendment, unless states join a compact that reaches a similar result. This question is about a direct national count.

0 ballots on the record, including demonstration ballots. Open the count

Arguments in favor

  • Each voter's ballot would carry the same weight in the national total, regardless of state.
  • Campaigns would have a reason to seek votes in every region, not only in closely divided states.
  • The winner would be the candidate with the most votes, which is how most other federal offices are filled.

Arguments in opposition

  • The current system can magnify a clear state-level win into a result that is easier to govern, and it requires support spread across states.
  • A national raw vote invites a national recount in a close election and raises the question of one uniform set of voting rules.
  • Smaller states would lose the extra influence the Constitution built into the electoral allotment.

These points summarize claims often made about this proposition. They are not a party platform, and CitizenVote does not endorse them. Both columns are given the same space.