Skip to content

IssuesBudget

Budget

Require the federal budget to balance over the economic cycle

The federal government routinely spends more than it collects and covers the difference with debt. Interest on that debt is a growing share of the budget. A balance rule would direct Congress to match spending and revenue over an economic cycle, allowing deficits in downturns if they are offset in expansions. Enforcement — automatic cuts, a supermajority to borrow, or another mechanism — would be written into the text. This question is about whether the obligation should exist.

0 ballots on the record, including demonstration ballots. Open the count

Arguments in favor

  • Borrowing shifts the cost of current programs onto future taxpayers.
  • A rule can force an explicit choice between lower spending and higher taxes, instead of an open-ended deficit.
  • If the text allows it, deficits can remain available in recessions and wars.

Arguments in opposition

  • A rigid rule can force cuts or tax increases at the wrong moment, because the economic cycle is hard to define in real time.
  • Congress can evade caps with emergency labels, timing shifts, and funds kept off the official budget.
  • Some public investments and defense costs are easier to justify with borrowing than with a same-year tax increase.

These points summarize claims often made about this proposition. They are not a party platform, and CitizenVote does not endorse them. Both columns are given the same space.